Caliban and the Witch: Women, The Body, and Primitive Accumulation
Reviewed by Chris Carlsson
LiP Magazine, June 21st 2005
I happen to live next to the Black Cat Collective, a self-described witch
coven. Like most of us who have not stopped to investigate the idea of witchcraft,
I have tended to think of it as a slightly ridiculous, premodern, superstition-based
set of practices. Seen through several centuries of prohibition, repression,
and deliberate and far-reaching propaganda, this is not surprising. I am somewhat
chastened about the absurdity of my own simplistic ideas in the wake of reading
Caliban and the Witch.
Caliban and the Witch is a brilliant book, largely focusing on the transition
from feudalism to capitalism and the period from the mid 1500s to the mid
1600s, in which the role of women was radically downgraded. Witch persecution,
Federici writes, corresponded with a sustained attempt to supplant traditional
subsistence economies with primitive accumulation and the brutal effort to
impose capitalism on resistant (usually indigenous) cultures.
To fully appreciate Federici’s serious investigation, we have to outline
her historical project. Witchcraft and the repression of witches did not arise
out of the blue, nor was it a phenomenon of the Middle Ages. In fact, by
Federici’s analysis, it was the success of the peasant revolts of the late
middle ages, and the steady erosion of feudal power, that set up a historically
unique crossroads in the late 1400s. One branch led to the world we’re in,
but another, long-forgotten road might have led to a communal, cooperative,
egalitarian alternative. The barbaric slaughter that ended the peasant revolts
in Europe put in motion the intolerant, incredibly violent, and enslaving
system of life from which modern capitalism emerged. Capitalism did not just
“take off,” Federici argues, but had to enslave Africans and, most importantly,
had to get control of the ultimate commodity—human labor—and the women who
were crucial to its reproduction. Thus the persecution of witches went hand
in hand with the construction of a new world order in which women were downgraded,
deskilled, and devalued. The persecution of witches doesn’t really begin until
the mid-16th century and continues to extend its reach for almost 100 years,
before being halted in the mid 1600s. Federici shows how ruling elites built
on the earlier campaign against heresy to alter social relations in ways
that were crucial to the expansion of the early capitalist mode of production.
As Marx documented, the beginnings of capitalism depended on a process of
primitive accumulation—a process we mostly think of in terms of dispossession,
of the private seizure of common lands and resources (forests, lakes, rivers),
and the social manufacture of a large population that had nothing to sell
but itself (as labor power for a wage). But Marx had a huge blind spot that
Federici strives to reveal: except for his remarks in the Communist Manifesto
on the use of women within the bourgeois family—as producers of heirs guaranteeing
the transmission of family property—Marx never acknowledged that procreation
could become a terrain of exploitation and by the same token a terrain of
resistance. He never imagined that women could refuse to reproduce, or that
such a refusal could become part of class struggle.
It is stunning (and yet, really not so surprising) that the 19th century
Marx would have been so oblivious to the transformation of social dynamics
at the end of the middle ages, crucially the repression of women. The foremost
analyst of capitalist dynamics, with his penetrating look at wage labor and
alienation, commodification and fetishism, completely overlooked the most
basic aspect of capitalist production, ie, the production of human labor.
Federici points out that the power difference between women and men and
the concealment of women’s unpaid labor under the cover of natural inferiority,
have enabled capitalism to immensely expand the ‘unpaid part of the working
day,’ and use the (male) wage to accumulate women’s labor; in many cases,
they have also served to deflect class antagonism into an antagonism between
men and women…. As we have seen, male workers have often been complicit with
this process…but [men have] paid the price of self-alienation, and the ‘primitive
disaccumulation’ of their own individual and collective powers.”
The book takes a close look at the historical process of “otherizing.” Federici
briefly recounts the church’s persecution of heretics in the 15th century
and earlier, and then shows how this type of campaign was redirected toward
women through criminalizing contraceptives and infanticide, and enforcing
pregnancy. The persecution of witches was the language of this effort. The
practice of midwifery was attacked and replaced by male-run obstetrics, and
eventually all female doctoring was outlawed and driven underground, whether
midwifery, herbology, or any other knowledge system developed over millennia.
It is not coincidental, according to Federici’s analysis, that this took place
at a time when the primary concern of the ruling elite was securing adequate
supplies of labor, at the dawn of capitalist development. The African slave
trade has its origins in this same era, as does the Conquest and the wholesale
slaughter of millions in the New World in pursuit of gold and other riches.
The final chapter shows how the language of witch persecution, of implacable
struggles against diabolical “others,” was extended to the New World, and
then with the stories of human sacrifice, sexual promiscuity, sodomy, etc.,
that came back to Europe, the logic was reinforced back in Europe, too. Ultimately,
Caliban and the Witch is an important historical corrective. It shows that
capitalism arose not as an organic process of improved systems and technological
breakthroughs supplanting older, less efficient, superstitious, primitive
societies. Rather, it arose through the violent imposition of divisions, showing
that primitive accumulation—the beginning process of capitalism—required sustained
barbarism and a hysterical and systematic century-long attack on women. And
that process eventually went considerably beyond women - thus, primitive
accumulation has been above all an accumulation of differences, inequalities,
hierarchies, divisions, which have alienated workers from each other and
even from themselves.
Today, we find a return of the language of “evil” and the dependence on
othering easily seen among Bush and his legions of fanatic Christian followers.
It’s interesting that the same language of diabolical possession that was
crucial to the imposition of high levels of exploitation at the dawn of capitalism
is now being directed at millions of workers in the Middle East—workers who
happen to be living on the largest supply of oil in the world. Here again,
we find the work of Federici and her comrades in the East Coast based Midnight
Notes collective most helpful: Check out their 1992 book, Midnight Oil, for
a longer look at oil politics and class struggle since the late ’60s.
